Is pop music getting more annoying?

Your answer to this question may be a resounding, non-hesitating, “Yes!” And I’m with you. Pop music nowadays can be really repetitive, uninteresting, and just irritating.

But even though it feels like pop music is more annoying than it used to be, is that actually true? And can the rest of us learn something from pop music?

The Pop Music Study

Back in 2017, a programmer and data nerd named Colin Morris wanted to answer the question, “Is pop music more repetitive than it used to be?”

And he wasn’t messing around.

He took 15,000 songs that charted on the Billboard Hot 100 between 1958 and 2017 and analyzed them.

He looked at the “number of unique words in a song, as a fraction of the total number of words.” Then he used some sort of dark-magic algorithm to spit out a concrete way to measure a song’s repetitiveness.

And repetitiveness, to me, usually equals “annoying.” At least when it’s overdone.

Here’s a nice little chart Morris made that shows us, yes, the most popular songs (as well as all songs in general) are getting more repetitive.

Screen Shot 2019-06-11 at 4.51.40 PM

In other words, the number-one song today is probably a lot more repetitive/annoying than a number-one song from 1965.

“The songs that reached the top 10 were, on average, more repetitive than the rest in every year from 1960 to 2015!” he writes.

And he said this is regardless of the genre that was popular at any given time. The Beatles, Justin Bieber, and Mariah Carey all have about the same score — each of them have above average repetitiveness in their songs that have charted.

Here’s another image that shows us each artist’s average repetitiveness in their songs compared to their peers:

Screen Shot 2019-06-11 at 4.51.52 PM

It’s not surprising Rihanna is winning in this game of repetitive songs (think “Umbrella” and “Diamonds”). But what’s interesting is that on both ends of the image above, you can see talented artists and songwriters.

For example, you’ve got The Beatles and Beyonce on the right and Billy Joel and Ray Charles on the left.

So what are we to make of this? Should we strive to use more repetition, or should we find inspiration from “the good ol’ days” when popular music had more variation?

The Takeaway for Songwriters

My big takeaway here is this: Repetitiveness in your songs is good until it’s not.

Obviously, you do need some repetition. If you never repeat a melody within a song, the listener will get overwhelmed and lost and turn it off. So it’s a good idea to have a chorus that repeats the most memorable melody and main lyrics at least two times.

But you don’t want to repeat those lyrics and melody over and over again until it annoys people. It’s all about balance. Hold repetition in one hand and surprise in the other.

RELATED: CLICK HERE to get 15% OFF The New Songwriter’s Workshop

Here’s what you do with a good song: you welcome the listener in with repetition. Get them comfortable. Offer them something to eat and drink as they get settled into the song’s armchair. Allow them to adapt to their surroundings.

Then bam! You hit them with surprise. You play a diminished 7th chord, you throw in a little vocal run, or you stop the music a couple beats before the big chorus.

You use repetition to set up the surprise. Repetition makes surprise that much more effective, and vice versa. You need both. They survive on each other.

So you don’t want to make music as annoying as Rihanna’s, but you may not want to write such obscure, non-repetitive music that you’re not on anyone’s radar.

So is pop music getting more annoying? I think so, but we can still learn from it.

I first wrote a version of this article for Sonicbids


Stay motivated, manage your time, and move toward your picture of success — grab the One-Thing-A-Day chart for FREE…

2 thoughts on “What Songwriters Can Learn From Annoying Pop Music

  1. A songwriter wrote Rhianna’s Songs.

    Some people prefer repetitive songs. I signed up for this newsletter months ago and this is the first email I’ve opened.

    Be objective.

    Don’t be another annoying cynical place on the internet.

  2. Hey, Steve.

    First, thanks for reading and subscribing.

    Second, I say in this post that repetitiveness is good, but (in my opinion) it can be overdone. I’m allowed to state my subjective opinion on my blog, and you’re allowed to comment your opinion. My objective takeaway is that we songwriters can learn from repetitive pop songs.

    I don’t think this article — when read in its entirety — is cynical. I used someone else’s study of pop music (which shows that pop music is objectively getting more repetitive) to draw the conclusion that repetitiveness in songs is good but can be overdone.

    My point is, balancing repetitiveness and surprise is key to good songwriting, IMO.

    Thanks for the comment!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.